With the growing importance of AI visibility, if you’re a service seller or you build sites for serviced based businesses, it pays to understand what helps you get mentions and citations in AI search responses so you can optimize your chances of being surfaced to prospective clients. At Circle Day 2026, Squarespace SEO Manager Tom Smeaton shared how AI has pivoted search from rankings to recommendations. Throughout his talk, he focused on:
How various AI search platforms tend to lean on different types of content when citing businesses
What types of content are most likely to help specific types of service providers achieve those recommendations and get noticed
Different platforms, different sources
To better understand what influences AI to make its recommendations, Squarespace collaborated with Peec AI to analyze 1.3 million linked inline citations in AI responses from ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, and Perplexity, specifically focusing on three types of service business categories:
Health and Wellness
Professional Services
Training and Education
Focusing on these three subverticals resulted in some important insights into how different AI models behave when searching across the service industry.
ChatGPT: Favors long-form and reference content, with 20%+ of citations coming from sources like Wikipedia, archived content, and academic papers.
Google AI Mode: Leans heavily on social content, with 90%+ of Instagram citations coming from AI Mode.
Perplexity: Prioritizes listicles and ranking-style content, which account for 33%+ of its cited sources.
Overall, 40% of cited sources came from listicle or article content types, whether individual brand blogs or affiliate sites and 3rd-party reviews.
Marketplaces and directories matter. They’re key discovery sources for AI models, especially in Health and Wellness and Professional Services.
UGC is important for AI visibility, too: Reddit, YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram can all influence what AI cites about services.
Still, each services subcategory had its own mix of sources and content that informed AI’s answers, which means knowing where your potential customers are looking is crucial to developing your content to attract AI’s attention.
Health and Wellness
In Health and Wellness, AI acts like a personal advisor and appointment booker, recommending specific businesses rather than ranked lists. Yelp, Booksy, YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram all play a significant role, making review listings, booking profiles, and video content critical sources for AI citations.
Professional Services
For Professional Services, recommendations tend to draw from Clutch, Goodfirms, Upwork, DesignRush, and “best-of” sites. Being represented across relevant directories and marketplaces can help service brands with AI visibility. LinkedIn Pulse also stands out, suggesting an opportunity to repurpose thought leadership and other brand content there.
Training and Education
The Training and Education subcategory pulls more heavily from tutorials, experiential videos, community forums, and chat groups. Beyond Yelp, niche learning platforms like Preply, Wyzant, and Superprof also appear frequently, making specialty directories and active participation in relevant communities worth considering.
Three strategies to build AI visibility
As Tom notes in his talk, while your website remains the biggest tool in your bag to attract potential clients, it also comes down to specific strategies that can help you show up in AI search.
Be discoverable: Show up in the directories and marketplaces your audience already uses—especially niche platforms like Yelp, Booksy, and category-specific listings.
Get validated: Build a presence wherever people are talking about and comparing businesses, from Facebook, Reddit, YouTube, and Instagram to niche editorial sites and listicles.
Create the right content: Give AI clear signals about your services, expertise, and credibility with well-structured service pages, helpful content, comparisons, and testimonials.
Your Squarespace website is just one piece of the discoverability puzzle—what you publish, where you’re listed, and how people talk about your business should all be part of your AI visibility strategy. The same principles apply to your clients. Incorporating these signals across every site and off-site presence you manage helps them get recommended, rather than just ranked.
Related resources:
Want more?
Join Squarespace Circle, Squarespace’s program for professional designers and web design agencies. Along with exclusive content, discounts, and other perks, Circle brings experts together from across the globe to exchange advice while connecting with new clients and collaborators.